667c22393295259d908df5df Picture1

Medium Voltage Switchgear Supply and Demand

June 26, 2024
Will the surge in undergrounding powerlines and the skyrocketing construction of data centers, exacerbated by the emergence of AI, create a backlog?

Operating within the 1 kV to 42 kV range, medium voltage (MV) switchgear plays a crucial role in controlling, protecting, and isolating electrical equipment. The US MV switchgear market, valued at around $2 billion, is projected to maintain a robust compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 10.5% until 2030 (Source: PTR). This substantial growth is propelled by key factors such as grid modernization, the emergence of data centers, and technological advancements in switchgear systems. 

Key Growth Drivers 

The growth in the MV switchgear market can be attributed to several driving factors, including: 

Grid Expansion 

The Biden-Harris administration's ambitious clean energy targets, aiming for 100% clean electricity by 2035 and a 50% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030, are set to significantly impact the US power grid. This shift towards renewable energy resources, distributed energy resources (DER), and electrification of the transport sector is expected to drive the growth of the MV switchgear market.  

To achieve 100% clean electricity, the US power grid must double its renewable generation capacity by 2030. Moreover, the Department of Energy (DOE) expects a surge in annual DER additions from 2025 to 2030, including 20 GW to 90 GW of demand capacity from EV charging infrastructure and 300 GWh to 540 GWh of storage capacity from EV batteries [Source: DOE]. 

The MV switchgear market is set to benefit from the rise of offshore wind. The US has set an active offshore wind target of 30GW of offshore deployments by 2030, introducing a significant demand for MV switchgear as these offshore wind projects are developed. 

PTR expects substantial growth in the number of MV substations in the US distribution sector, driven by the need to enhance capacity for DER integration, Electric Vehicle (EV) charging loads, etc. The market for MV substations alone is projected to grow at a CAGR of over 5% from 2024 to 2030, with the installed base reaching nearly 22,000 MV substations—an increase of almost 1,000 substations, a significant number for this sector. PTR's research indicates that utilities also modernize substations by retrofitting switchgear, which increases demand. 

In the USA, independent system operators have grid expansion programs that will increase MV switchgear requirements through substation upgrades. These programs include: 

MISO: The MTEP2023 plan includes $8.9 billion for critical regional power grid upgrades, focusing on local reliability and aging infrastructure. This plan includes $2.6 billion for substation retrofits, maintenance, and greenfield deployments. 

CAISO: The 2022-2023 transmission planning cycle involves extensive stakeholder activities, culminating in the ISO Transmission Plan. This plan assesses grid reliability and efficiency over a 10-year period, addressing system limitations and substation upgrades. 

ERCOT: The 2023 Regional Transmission Plan (RTP), developed with stakeholder input, outlines a six-year horizon for reliability and economic studies. It identifies 173 projects, including $55 million for substation upgrades. 

ISO New England: The Regional System Plan Project List forecasts approximately $1.5 billion in transmission reliability investments through 2027, with 29 active projects, including major developments in Massachusetts and Maine, which include substation upgrades and deployments 

SPP: The 2024 Transmission Expansion Plan (STEP) details all transmission projects over a 20-year horizon, including 126 approved network upgrades with substation projects totaling $90 million. 

Enhancing Grid Resilience and Reliability 

The drive for enhanced grid resilience and reliability also catalyzes the MV switchgear market. Initiatives such as the Grid Resilience and Innovation Partnerships Program (GRIP) and the Grid Innovation Program have spurred investments in undergrounding electrical infrastructure. These initiatives aim to protect the grid from weather-related disruptions and other hazards by relocating electrical cables and equipment below ground, thereby improving overall reliability. The increased need for underground MV switchgear installations to support these resilient networks is a significant growth driver. 

The Rise of Data Centers 

The expansion of data centers is another critical factor propelling the growth of the MV switchgear market. With advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) and the increasing reliance on cloud computing, the number of data centers in the US is booming. Data centers require reliable power supply systems to ensure continuous operation and MV switchgear plays a vital role in this infrastructure. According to PTR estimates, the MV switchgear market in the data center segment is expected to grow at a CAGR of 16% from 2023 to 2030 in terms of investments. This growth is driven by the need for high-performance and reliable electrical systems to support the data-intensive operations of modern AI applications.  

As the deployment and use of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies expand, power density per rack in data centers is expected to increase significantly. Currently, the average power density per rack ranges from 6 kW to 8 kW. However, in large hyperscale data centers, this figure can reach nearly 20 kW and has the potential to rise to between 50 kW and 75 kW per rack. 

Data center operators adopt parallel supply paths from utility connections to efficiently manage this increasing power density. This approach necessitates the deployment of multiple units of MV switchgear. By implementing this design scheme, the data center can significantly drive demand for MV switchgear. Furthermore, this strategy enables data centers to achieve 99.99% uptime in a cost-effective manner without fully transitioning to Tier 3 or Tier 4 configurations. 

Technology and Application Trends 

Changes in switchgear technology also impact the MV switchgear market, making it imperative to study these trends. 

Underground Switchgear 

PTR forecasts the US MV underground switchgear market revenue to experience a CAGR of 7.2% between 2023 and 2030, with the annual market for underground switchgear units expected to be nearly twice as large in 2030 compared to 2023. Currently, pad-mounted switchgear dominates the market with a substantial 75% share. However, this dominance is anticipated to decrease as utilities shift towards underground switchgear due to urban expansion, infrastructure development, and the need for reliable power distribution in densely populated areas.  

Electric utilities must enhance grid resilience and reliability, and undergrounding is gaining momentum as a viable solution, especially in high-risk areas prone to natural hazards such as wildfires and flooding. 

The Dominion Energy Strategic Underground Program aims to shift outage-prone lines underground in Virginia. 

In California, Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E) has plans to shift 10,000 miles of powerlines underground in high wildfire-risk areas across the state. 

In Florida, Florida Light and Power Company’s (FPL) undergrounding program states that 45% of their total distribution system has shifted to underground lines, and 90% of new lines are underground. 

In Iowa, RTO PJM has greenlit a 550km pilot undergrounding project for the MISO grid.  

Transition to Gas-Insulated and Solid Insulated Switchgear 

Historically, the US market has predominantly used Air-Insulated Switchgear (AIS). In contrast, Europe has favored Gas-Insulated Switchgear (GIS) due to its compact design and suitability for urban environments. However, with the increasing trend towards undergrounding in the US, there is a growing shift towards GIS and Solid Insulated Switchgear (SIS) for underground installations. GIS and SIS are more suitable for underground applications due to their compact size and better insulation properties. PTR research indicates that SIS market shares will increase from 23% in 2024 to 30% in 2030 in the underground switchgear market compared to GIS, which drops from 27% in 2024 to 25% in 2030. This technology shift is attributed to SIS's superior reliability compared to the GIS for underground installations, and hence, SIS will surpass GIS for these installations. Additionally, the rise in wind power installations, which typically utilize GIS, further drives this shift. As a result, the demand for GIS is expected to grow in the US market. 

Adoption of SF6-Free Technology 

Another significant trend in the MV switchgear market is the move towards SF6-free technology. Due to environmental concerns, Europe has already started phasing out SF6 and plans a complete ban on SF6 MV switchgear by 2026. Although the US has no country-wide regulations banning SF6, many global manufacturers are transitioning to SF6-free alternatives. This shift is also anticipated to influence the US market, as it would be inefficient for manufacturers to maintain separate production lines for SF6 and SF6-free switchgear. A few major manufacturers plan to phase out SF6 globally across their operations, and hence, their US operations will also undergo the phase. As such, other manufacturers are expected to adopt SF6-free technologies over the next decade, driven by the global shift towards environment-friendly technologies. 

Lead Time Challenges 

The supply side of the MV switchgear market has faced significant challenges, particularly lead times. Pre-COVID-19, lead times for MV switchgear were around 12-16 weeks. However, the pandemic disrupted supply chains and manufacturing processes, resulting in extended lead times and delays. This hampered distributor sales and hindered the performance of other manufacturers whose products could not be installed until switchgear was available for a project. The lead times then increased to roughly 52 weeks in the COVID period. 

The pandemic highlighted supply chain issues, inducing transportation delays and factory shutdowns. While many of these issues have since been resolved in the post-pandemic era, the industry is now facing an increased uptake in computing applications, which requires more data centers, and the rise of AI, which demands even more power and data infrastructure. Additionally, utilities are investing billions into infrastructure, which must be spent within a short timeframe, focusing on electrification, industrial reshoring, and utility grid enhancements. 

In response, switchgear manufacturers are expected to invest in new factories and expand the capacity of existing facilities. However, building these facilities takes time, and they must hire and train staff, leading to inevitable delays. 

Post-pandemic lead times have improved, yet they remain above pre-COVID levels, averaging between 26 and 32 weeks. While not as severe as the lead times for transformers, which have faced even more significant delays (and price escalation), the extended lead times for MV switchgear pose challenges for utilities and infrastructure projects. Efforts to streamline supply chains and increase production capacity are expected to gradually reduce lead times, reaching nearly 24 weeks by 2027. However, the ongoing demand surge will continue to pressure the supply side. 

In response to the growing demand for switchgear, manufacturers have expanded their manufacturing facilities to alleviate supply chain issues and cater to the existing and forecasted demand.  

In 2024, Vertiv expects to double its global manufacturing capacity for switchgear, busway, and integrated modular solutions to support the increased demand.  

Similarly, Schneider Electric unveiled plans to invest $140 million in 2024 to expand its US manufacturing presence, explicitly targeting critical infrastructure equipment, including MV switchgear. 

Conclusion 

The US MV switchgear market is expected to grow, driven by the increasing need for grid resilience, the expansion of data centers, and technological advancements. While the market has historically favored Air Insulated Switchgear, the shift towards Gas-Insulated Switchgear, driven by undergrounding trends and wind power installations, is set to enhance the landscape. The transition to SF6-free technologies and the adoption of underground and digital switchgear further highlight the market's evolution towards more sustainable and advanced solutions. Despite supply-side challenges, the future of the US MV switchgear market remains promising, with continued investments in infrastructure and technology driving its growth.    

About the Author

Saqib Saeed | Principal Analyst

Saqib is co-founder and principal analyst at Power Technology Research. He is an expert in power system design and power electronics components. He has prior experience in commissioning and maintenance of power systems. Since 2015, he has been involved in consulting projects with transmission and distribution (T&D) OEMs and utilities conducting online and offline market research to identify business opportunities for equipment manufacturers like HVDC, FACTS, transformers and switchgear.

About the Author

Abdullah Karman

Abdullah Kamran is a Market Analyst at PTR Inc. He focuses on the topic of energy storage and battery energy storage systems. He does research on the global energy storage market, covering areas such as market sizing of different markets, policy landscapes, market developments, pipelines of projects, installations of these projects and the development of new battery technologies. He also covers the battery value chain and tracks the supply chain advancements in the industry, such as the installation of raw material plants and battery gigafactories. His work involves an in-depth analysis of the aforementioned topics, and the creation of various reports on related topics. He has worked on several custom studies related to his area of expertise, enhancing PTR's knowledge of the topic. He holds a BS in Electrical Engineering from Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS).  

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of T&D World, create an account today!